A socialist manifesto for education

 Dave Hill is a supporter of Socialist Resistance and the Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition parliamentary candidate for Brighton Kemptown. He offers his alternative to the market driven education “reforms” of the other parties.

I have spent my lifetime as a teacher in `challenging’ primary and secondary schools and in teacher `training’ and in universities trying to tackle inequalities in schooling- inequalities that result in millions of working class children having far less educational opportunities- and subsequently, usually lower paid jobs- than the children of richer parents, especially the 7% who go to private schools- and snap up most of the highest paid, elite, jobs.

The very choice of what and how it should be taught, how and what schooling should be organised, how any whom it should be funded, and where and how the funding should be targeted, and a consideration of `who wins and who loses’ through all of the above, are all intensely political. And we want that politics to be in the interests of the millions not the millionaires!

I come from a working class family brought up in some poverty, for example on free School Meals (like a million others!) in St. Martins’ St., off the Lewes Rd., Brighton. I went to Westlain Grammar School, my brothers to underfunded secondary modern schools, such as Queens Park and Moulscoomb. Three times as much was spent on the education of grammar school students than on Secondary Modern students! My children went to local state schools. The inequalities I have witnessed- and lived- as a child, and as a teacher and socialist political activist, have led me to spending my life fighting for greater equality in education and society, and against racism, sexism and against homophobia.

What an indictment of our divisive education system that students from private schools are 25 times more likely to get to one of the top British universities than those who come from a lower social class or live in a poor area. And that (in 2008), only 35% of pupils eligible for free school meals obtained five or more A* to C GCSE grades, compared with 63% of pupils from wealthier backgrounds. This stark education inequality mirrors that in our grossly unequal society.

It is incredible, actually it is only too believable, that in Britain today, the richest section of society have 17 years of healthy life more than the least well-off in society. The minimum wage should be raised by 50%. How can people- decent hard working people like some in my own family, live on take-home pay of less than £200 a week! And there should be a maximum wage, too! Nobody, banker, boss, or buy-out bully, should be on more than £250,000 a year- (and this figure should reduce progressively so that within 10 years no-one is taking more than four times the average wage, nobody should be creaming off £27 million or £90 million a year for example! Certainly not when there are 4 million children living in poverty! I was once one of them. I was helped by the welfare state. We need our public services. We need to improve them, not cut them, not attack them.

All three parties, New Labour, LibDem, Tory, dance to the music of big business. All are promising cuts. Whatever they say, those cuts will hit schools, children, and the quality of education in our state schools. Already we are seeing staff cuts and course closures in universities up and down the country. In Brighton, for example, both Brighton and Sussex Universities are promising to cut out the nurseries, and Sussex to chop over 100 jobs. Brighton University is proposing to cut its Adult Ed art courses. Vandalism! Cutting popular and widely used public services!’

And don’t believe cuts are necessary. They’re not! Cutting the Trident nuclear submarine replacement programme, bringing troops home from Afghanistan and Iraq, stopping the Identity Card programme, and collecting even some even of the £120 billion in taxes unpaid by the rich… yes, £120 billion! And raising taxes high earners…would mean cuts are not necessary at all!

But you won’t hear that from the other parties, just from Socialists, like the Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition, and from Respect.

A socialist manifesto is:

1. Cut class sizes (they are currently some of the largest in the rich world- much larger than in private schools for example). According to OECD research Britain is 23rd out of 30 developed countries in terms of large class size. Other countries such as Finland have a maximum class size of 20. Finland is widely seen as providing an extremely high quality of education. For a maximum class size of 20 by 2020 in both primary and secondary schools!’

2. Abolish league tables and abolish SATS (some external testing is necessary, but SATS so very often restricts teaching to `teaching to the test’, and results in undue stress (and an increase in bedwetting, compared to the pre-SATS era, for example).

3. Restore local democratic control of `Academies’. They should be run by the democratically elected local councils, and keep to national pay and conditions agreements. Why should rich businessmen and women take control of any of our schools? Let’s keep the added investment- but it’s the government that pays for that added investment anyhow! Let’s keep and enhance the added investment, but distribute it fairly between all schools. Our schools and the children in them are not for sale! Nor, through uneven funding for different types of school (e.g. academies) should some schools be set up for success at the expense of others being set up (and underfunded) for relative failure.

4. Private profiteering out of our schools! Bring the education services hived off to private profiteers back into either national or local private ownership! These include Ofsted, Student grants, school meals, cleaning and caretaking.

5. Free, nutritious, balanced school meals for every child to combat poor diets, obesity, and… yes… for some children… hunger!

6. Restore free adult education classes in pastime and leisure studies as well as in vocational training/ studies

7. Restore free funded residential centres and Youth Centres/ Youth clubs for our children so they can widen their experiences of life in safe circumstances and enhance their education beyond the confines of the home or city.

8. For a fully Comprehensive Secondary School system, so that each school has a broad social class mix and mix of ability and attainment levels.

9. For the integration of Private schools into the state education system– so that the goodies of the private school system are shared amongst all pupils/ students. All schools to be under democratic locally elected local council control. No to Private Schools. No to religious groups running schools. No to big business / private capital running our schools and children!

10. Free up the curriculum so there can be more creativity and cross-subject/ disciplinary work.

11. Get Ofsted and their flawed tick-box system off the back of teachers. The results of Ofsted are to penalise even the best schools (outstanding in every aspect- other than in SATS attainments) in the poorest areas.

12. Encourage Critical Thinking across the curriculum. Teach children not `what to think’, but also `how to think’. Including how to think critically about the media and politicians.

13. Teach in schools for ecological literacy and a readiness to act for environmental justice as well as economic and social justice Encourage children to `reach for the stars- and to work for a society that lets that happen- a fairer society with much more equal chances, pay packets and power, and about environmental and sustainability issues.

14. Proper recognition of all school workers, and no compulsory redundancies. For teachers, secretarial and support staff, teaching assistants, school meals supervisory assistants, caretaking staff, there should be workplace democratic regular school forums in every school. Regarding jobs (for example the threatened job cuts at Sussex University- and the `inevitable’ job cuts in every? school after the election- no compulsory redundancies- any restructuring to be conditional on agreement with the unions.

15. Setting up of school councils – to encourage democratic understanding, citizenship, social responsibility, and a welcoming and valuing of `student/ pupil voice’.

16. Ensuring that schools are anti-racist, anti-sexist and anti-homophobic- making sure schools encourage equality, welcome different home and group cultures.. As part of this, anti-bullying practices in every school must be fully implemented, to combat bullying of all sorts, including racism, sexism, homophobia, and bullying based on disabilities. And this should be not just in anti-bullying policies, but also be part of the curriculum too!

17. An honest sex education curriculum in schools that teaches children not just `when to say no’, but also when to say `yes’, a programme that is focuses on positives and pleasure and personal worth, not on stigmatising sex and sexualities.

18. No to `Faith Schools’ and Get organised religion out of schools. If Christians, Jews, Muslims, Hindus, Zoroastrians, or whichever religion wishes to teach religion, let them do it in their own time, places of worship (Saturday/ Sunday schools) or in their supplementary or complementary schools. Teach ethics and spirituality by all means, and teach about religions. But no brainwashing. Teach a critical approach to religions.

19. Broaden teacher education and training so that the negative effects of the `technicisation and detheorising’ of teacher training (that were the result of the 1992/1993 Conservative re-organisation of what was then called teacher education- subsequently retitled teacher training). Bring back the study and awareness of the social and political and psychological contexts of teaching, including an understanding of and commitment to challenge and overturn racism, sexism, homophobia and other forms of underexpectation and discrimination- such as discrimination against working class pupils.

20. A good, local school for every child. No school closures! “Surplus places” should actually mean lower class sizes! And increased community use of school facilities.

21. A completely fully funded, publicly owned and democratic education system from pre-school right through to university. Education is a right not a commodity to be bought and sold. So, no fees, like in Scandinavia, Cuba, Venezuela, Bolivia, where education up to PhD level is free. No university of further education/ vocational training fees, and a living grant for students from less well-off backgrounds/ income.

In my jobs, firstly as a teacher, and now as a Professor of Education (and writer/ editor of 17 books on education and equality) I have been round hundreds of schools. Many of them are brilliant. Schools in the poorest areas, schools in better off areas! Brilliant. But, with better funding, smaller class sizes, an end to the destructive competition between schools (if every school is a good local school) and with more professional judgement being allowed for teachers- then I look forward to a time when all state schools match the class sizes and results of the currently more lavishly funded private schools’. And working class kids – black, brown, white- get the fair deal currently trumpeted- but in actuality denied- by all three major parties. 

Prof. Dave Hill, The Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition (TUSC) parliamentary candidate for Brighton Kemptown

Prof. Dave Hill teaches at Middlesex University and is Visiting Professor of Critical Education Policy and Equality Studies at the University of Limerick, Ireland.

The Brighton Trade Unionist and Socialist Cioalition blogspot is at www.brightontusc.blogspot.com

Dave’s wiki and publications are at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Hill_(professor)

Share this:

2 Comments on A socialist manifesto for education

  1. Patrick Black // 18th April 2010 at 6:27 pm // Reply

    I was interested to read this Socialist manifesto for education which contains many good and valid ideas. I think it could form the basis for a LONG OVERDUE wide ranging discussion about the advancement of a viable and coherent Socialist education manfesto for the future. How we get there is of course another matter.

    In addition, I think we need to question the size of schools as well as class sizes and personally am more interested in the development of Community based which are easily manageable at both primary and secondary school level.

    Critical thinking and creativity,practical and relevant learning,emotional and academic intelligence,care and compassion, cooperation(as against capitalist competition),internationalism(as opposed to imperialism),the promotion of positve self image and self respect and a deep respect for humanity and solidarity ,for a cohesive and caring community and society and for all individuals, women and men, lesbian and gay,young and old, for all people with disabilities and able bodied people and of all races and cultures, for the ecology of the planet all should form the basis for learning.

    There should be space for spiritual education within schools and a recognition of the importance of meditation and yoga which should be taught from a young age to all children.

    In respect to learning subjects especially in relation to history and politics, such as the profoundly imperialist and colonial nature of British society, both past and present should brought into a sharp critical perspective within the educational experience of all children.

    Popular education and the ideas of Paulo Friere have a great role to play in this respective.

    Critical thinking and creative learning, mutual respect individual and cooperative learning should form the basis of teacher education which should be thorough going and comprehensive such that no teacher should be allowed to teach unless fully able and competent.

    Effective collective Team teaching should be become much more the norm in both primary and secondary education and staffing levels should be based on a needs basis so that all pupils are properly catered for irrespective of ability or disability.

    I would also like to see much more attention and public funds focussed on “creative play” and the development of creativity and imagination both as an individual and as part of a collective and the vital importance of play as the basis for education(and continuing lifelong learning and education) and similarly in respect to the arts with a given committment to a fundamental rethinking and a more central repositioning of the vital importance of all creative arts subjects within a broad and dynamic curriculum from art to drama, dance, theatre, film, video and photography, music etc etc.

    Any kind of radical socialist reform of and transition from the present capitalist education system needs to involve teachers, school staff, parents, children and adult users of education alike.

    I am fully in favour of private schools being taken into public ownership and the trial and criminal conviction of many private school teachers who were and to some extent still are involved in the systematic abuse,the physical, emotional and psychological abuse of generations of children

    A socialist education system like a socialist health system should be “free”for all at the point of entry and delivery but based on a fully comprehensive,equitable and progressive form of taxation.

    Perhaps we should be looking at an integrated socialist education and health system whereby individuals learn about the importance of health,emotional, mental, sexual, physical spiritual and psychological health and healthy living in all respects especially healthy eating regarding, being healthy and fit,positive self esteem, self image especialy in respect to sexual health and sexuality.

  2. Dave Edwards // 1st May 2010 at 6:50 pm // Reply

    A Conservative-commissioned report has set out plans to overhaul the qualifications and assessment system and change the way league tables work. Sir Richard Sykes has made 21 recommendations, chief among which is a return to a ‘traditional’, non-modular A Level in which students sit exams at the end of a two-year course. There would be a US-style SAT test alongside A Levels to assess general English and Maths skills. GCSEs would also be radically changed, with students taking exams for a ‘greatly reduced’ number of subjects, allowing for a greater concentration on English and Maths. Schools would be prevented from putting students forward for exams in subjects that ‘lack rigour’ in order to inflate their league table position.
    This idea of ‘traditionalism’ is interesting to explore. In pure ‘learning’ terms progressive educational experiences and such structures as modules in exams (if we must have them) end up with a workforce that ‘fits’ the needs of capitalism. So all this traditional stuff shows that there is more than some ‘direct’ relationship between the needs of capital for trained labour and the education system (ha ha! an interesting question!)

    Something to explore in the ‘reactionary’ backlog that’s in all this traditional approach. Where is it coming from, why and does it have a logical function…. More questions opening up here.

4 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Twitter Trackbacks for A socialist manifesto for education : Socialist Resistance: Fourth International in Britain [socialistresistance.org] on Topsy.com
  2. Fighting neo-liberalism with education and activism « Philosophers for Change
  3. A socialist manifesto for education « RADICAL NOTES Journal
  4. A socialist manifesto for education « radicalnotesblog

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.